基于文献计量学分析我国器官捐献和移植领域的伦理研究现状和进展

Bibliometric analysis of the current status and progress of ethical research in the field of organ donation and transplantation in China

  • 摘要:
    目的 通过文献计量学分析我国器官捐献和移植领域伦理研究的进展和现状。
    方法 检索中国知网期刊数据库2000年1月至2023年12月的主题文献,应用CiteSpace 6.2.6从发文量、核心作者合作网络、发文机构合作网络、关键词共现、关键词突现及关键词聚类等进行分析。
    结果 检索共获得有效文献399篇,发文量趋势中的3次高峰受到政策时事和移植技术发展影响。2000年至2014年,发文量呈上升趋势,该阶段研究关注器官捐献和移植领域的伦理学思辨;2015年至2023年发文量呈波动趋势,该阶段关注捐献和移植工作体系和医疗实践下伦理问题,公民逝世后器官捐献、伦理审查等成为研究前沿。作者共现知识图谱反映出作者以单独节点为主,缺乏作者群之间交流,发文核心作者有25位。发文机构来源多样,包括高校医学相关院系、伦理学研究机构、医院器官移植科室、医院伦理委员会、人体器官获取组织(OPO)等,发文量最多的单位是昆明市第一人民医院。共提取252个关键词,13个突现词,突现度最强的关键词为脑死亡、器官捐献、立法、伦理审查。共生成14个关键词聚类,聚类主题包括器官移植、器官捐献、公民逝世后器官捐献、伦理道德、伦理审查、医务人员。
    结论 器官捐献和移植伦理研究领域的作者和机构合作不足,应促进多中心研究和作者间合作。建议加强基于当前工作体系和医疗实践的伦理问题挖掘和实证研究,为器官捐献和移植事业的改革与实践提供伦理基础和辩护。

     

    Abstract:
    Objective To analyze the progress and current status of ethical research in the field of organ donation and transplantation in China by bibliometric analysis.
    Methods Literature review was conducted from CNKI between January 2000 to December 2023. The number of published articles, the cooperation network of core authors, the cooperation network of publication institutions, the co-occurrence of keywords, the emergent keywords and the clustering of keywords were analyzed by CiteSpace 6.2.6.
    Results A total of 399 valid articles were obtained. The three peaks in the trend of published articles were affected by current policy events and the development of transplantation technology. From 2000 to 2014, the number of published articles showed an upward trend. At this stage, these studies focused on ethical speculation in the field of organ donation and transplantation. From 2015 to 2023, the number of published articles showed a fluctuating trend. During this stage, these researches highlighted the work system of donation and transplantation and ethical issues in medical practice. Organ donation and ethical review after citizen death became the research frontiers. The co-occurrence knowledge map of authors reflected that the authors mainly served as single nodes, lacking of communication among authors. Twenty-five core authors were identified. Diverse publication institutions were searched including medical departments from colleges and universities, ethics research institutions, organ transplantation departments from hospitals, ethics committees from hospitals and human Organ Procurement Organization (OPO), etc. The First Hospital of Kunming published the largest number of articles. A total of 252 keywords and 13 emergent words were extracted. The keywords with the highest degree of emergency consisted of brain death, organ donation, legislation and ethical review. A total of 14 keyword clusters were generated, including organ transplantation, organ donation, organ donation after citizen’s death, ethics, ethical review and medical staff.
    Conclusions The cooperation among authors and institutions is insufficient in the field of organ donation and transplantation ethics. Multi-center research and cooperation among authors should be strengthened. Extensive efforts should be made to strengthen the exploration and empirical research of ethical issues based on current work system and medical practice, aiming to provide ethical basis and defense for the reform and practice of organ donation and transplantation.

     

/

返回文章
返回